My favourite stories were a letter to harvey milk written from the point of view of the old man in the retirement home who had met h. William milk s funeral had particular significance for another member of the family. For all this, i felt that milk is a slightly staid film, closer to the middleoftheroad side of gus van sants film making persona, the bland side that made his treacly sean connery film finding. Harvey milk 1974 by rob epstein one among the foremost feature documentaries that revolve around american gay life, rob epsteins the times of harvey milk, is a creation of advocacy, taking harvey s message of equality and hope to a larger audience. He dramatically burns his bankamericard in protest. Milk was murdered in november 1978 by a former colleague, dan white. Super 8 footage of harvey milk in his suit on wall street, his hair just a tiny bit longer. If only harvey milk were alive to help fight for a cure for aids. After graduating from the new york state college for teachers in albany 1951, milk served in the u. The beginning of the documentary is powerful and it seems director robert epstein knew that this would be one of the best ways to draw the viewers into the.
The film depicts milk s life and career after he moved to frisco from new york in 1972 up until his assassination in 1978. Jack lira came from mexico, but his father beat him when he discovered that his son was gay, leading to lira heading for san francisco in the us state of california. Milk is a 2008 american biographical film based on the life of gay rights activist and politician harvey milk, who was the first openly gay person to be elected to public office in california, as a member of the san francisco board of supervisors. Using flashbacks from a statement recorded late in life and archival footage for atmosphere, this film traces harvey milk s career from his 40th birthday to his death.
He has been immortalized in the names of the harvey milk democratic club formerly the san francisco gay democratic club, harvey milk high school in new york, and san franciscos annual harvey milk memorial parade. As he narrates, we catch glimpses of milk in front of various groups, giving speeches, using attentiongetting opening lines that vary with every crowd. The film charts the last eight years of harvey milk s life. Registrations close one 1 week prior to the start of class. Navy during the korean war and was discharged in 1955 milk later said that he was dishonourably discharged due to his homosexuality, but. In 2009, then governor arnold schwarzenegger signed sb 572 into law. Analysis of the times of harvey milk essay 1204 words. Untitled screenplay text document stephen follows film. In light of the groundswell of movement in opposition to the passage of proposition 8. Stuart milk, the son of robert and audrey milk, and harvey milk s nephew. The times of harvey milk was shown as part of the 1984 new york film festival. In short, harvey milk was the first openly gay man elected to political office he was elected to the san francisco board of supervisors in 1977. The selfproclaimed mayor of castro street, new york stockbroker turned san francisco activist harvey milk rose to prominence as the first openly gay politician elected to public office in california.
His is a story of personal tragedies and political intrigues, assassination in city hall and massive riots in the streets, the. A collection of photos, videos, and grainy period film include. Im also bringing it up because many have seen or heard of the eponymous film about harvey milk and starring sean penn but may not know how far from reality the film s depiction of milk is. Dramatising milk s life, black and van sant see these qualities developing as harvey goes into business in san franciscos castro district, running a camera shop with scott, recruiting gay people. Academy award winner sean penn stars as harvey milk under the direction of academy award nominee gus van sant in the new movie filmed on location in san francisco from an original screenplay by dustin lance black and produced by academy award winners dan jinks and bruce cohen. We are working diligently to reschedule and notify students as more information becomes available. This movie, like the man, is brash, charismatic, unapologetic and uncompromising.
Harvey bernard milk may 22, 1930 november 27, 1978 was an american politician and the first openly gay elected official in the history of california, where he was elected to the san francisco board of supervisors. There are two mainly renowned films about harvey milk, which will be compared for this essay. Harvey s story of overcoming bigotry and prejudice to inspire others and effect change evokes the betterknown stories of african american civil rights. Starting out when harvey milk was growing up in woodmere, new york, the book traces his life from there. The times of harvey milk was released during the height of the aids pandemic. Harvey milk became one of the first openly gay officials in the united states in 1977 when he was elected to the san francisco board of supervisors. Harvey milk was the first openly gay person to be elected to public office in california. Film evokes memories for milks relatives the new york times. Milk is a civil rights film about harvey milk, a prominent american gay rights activist in the 1970s who became the first openly gay man to be elected to public office in california. The truth about harvey milk illinois family institute. The times of harvey milk 1984 by rob epstein and milk 2008 by gus van sant. Fast forward to 2008 and the lgbtq community has had. The times of harvey milk starts with the climactic scene where the first thing the viewers see is the announcement of the killing of harvey milk and san franciscos mayor george moscone.
Jack lira died 1978 was an american gay rights activist who was one of the lovers of harvey milk during the 1970s. This is harvey milk speaking on friday november 18th. The film chronicles his political career and, as it befits his campaigns and issues, his personal life as well. Its a pretty straightforward biography and never tries to be anything flashier. How sean penn finally assassinated harvey milk esquire. As this film seeks to demonstrate, all gay men owe a debt to harvey milk. Harvey milk american politician and activist britannica. After being discharged from the united states navy, milk spent many hours taking pictures.
Social and political themes in the movie milk essay bartleby. In 1977, harvey milk was elected to the san francisco board of supervisors, becoming the first openly gay man to be voted into public office in america. From senior citizens to union workers, harvey milk changed the very nature of what it. Do not update your account with the new information until you have heard from us. Under ksheera bhagya yojana nutritious milk scheme, about 10 million. Milk, gus van sants film project that was close to two decades in the making, was released on the 26th of november 2008 and marks the 30th anniversary of harvey milk s death and the brief but brilliant political career he led. Rob sanders, the story of harvey milk and the rainbow flag, penguin, 2018. A person worth documenting is harvey milk, the first openly gay elected official in the united states who fought for gay rights and inspired equality for the united states. Harvey milk s speeches and writings, university of california press, 20. A teenager at the time, stuart milk recalled that he was coming to terms with. Scene about how is important come out from oscar film milk. Milk tells harvey milk s story as one of a transformed life, a victory for individual freedom over state persecution, and a political and social cause. Milk is a 2008 film, that was directed by gus van sant and stars sean penn, emile hirsch, james franco, and josh brolin. If you agree with harvey, milk tells us, youre aok.
Not since the accident at three mile island disaster occurred mere days after the release of the nuclear disaster film the china syndrome has there been a convergence of topical events aligned with the release of a film as will happen when the biographical film about harvey milk starring sean penn is released. Combining archive footage, which almost makes this biopic a documentary, with acute attention to detail, this film s two hours completely captivated me. There are hundreds of images of smith, taken by milk and others, in the harvey milk archivesscott smith collection at the san francisco public library. The mayor of castro street is shiltss acclaimed story of harvey milk, the man whose personal life, public career, and tragic assassination mirrored the dramatic and unprecedented emergence of the gay community in america during the 1970s. By the time milk was elected to a city supervisor position in the 70s, san francisco was already a gay mecca, but the presence of a successful gay politician was such an anomaly at the time. In addition, there are two academy award winning films about milk, a documentary and a fictionalized film.
Discuss the overall significance of the events portrayed in the film and how they relate to changes in american society. Learn how successful people in the customer service harvey milk resume film field presented themselves to potential employers many writing companies balance their services against high prices and hidden costs. Due to bay area health guidelines related to covid19, harvey milk photo center classes are currently cancelled. Harvey bernard milk was born on may 22, 1930, in woodmere, new york. The narration of this film is carried out by harvey milk speaking into a tape recorded in 1978, dictating a letter to be read or in this case, listened to only in the event of his assassination.
The mayor of castro street is proof positive that he the author can turn even the most mundane of political machinations into high drama. This is not necessarily the case, and the weakest element in the times of harvey milk is its willingness to let milk s friends secondguess the jury, and impugn the jurors motives. Milk is much more than a martyr movie film critic david edelstein says the harvey milk biopic, starring sean penn, is one of the most heartfelt portraits of a politician ever made. Harvey milk was unfortunately gunned down on november 27th 1978, three weeks after his biggest political victory. Younger students will enjoy this childrens book about harvey milk. There is a remarkable shot near the end, showing a candlelight march reaching as far as the eyes can see. How harvey milk changed the gay rights movement duration. Milk just wanted fair and equal representation, he didnt necessarily have to be the one to be in office. By the documentary release, over 7600 people were diagnosed with aids in the united states while over 3600 people had already died from the virus. Harvey milk, american politician and gayrights activist.
1264 1065 801 120 47 501 623 500 639 976 126 1128 494 1414 1027 981 1436 1405 76 782 713 1464 982 4 839 570 1198 432 669 1083 445 1060 664